Dave ja vu for Cormack: Yet another wrong appointment?
With the Dons struggling both domestically and on the European front, Thomas Harper begs the question; is it third time unlucky for Aberdeen chairman Dave Cormack and the “Football Monitoring Board”?

The Chairman of Aberdeen Football Club has a responsibility to pick the right management team, and, with help from his “Football Monitoring Board” and CEO Alan Burrows, he decided that Barry Robson’s purple patch was too good to ignore – a 2-0 win over Rangers at Pittodrie being the highlight of his interim spell.
Fast forward a few months and millions of pounds have been spent on new transfers in Barry’s vision. Aberdeen are playing UEFA group stage football for the first time since 2007, so investment was clearly needed to compete on such a big stage. For such a talented group of players, the lack of managerial acumen from Robson has meant the squad has been reduced to shadows of their former selves – most notably Luis “Duk” Lopes and Leighton Clarkson, who are very much out of form at the moment.
I feel sorry for Dave Cormack – it looks like another disastrous appointment from him. Robson made it impossible for him not to be hired, the atmosphere around the club was extremely positive thanks to his results. Fans and players alike were in dreamland – the players were enjoying their football, while the fans were watching their heroes play the football they had craved for years.
Only time will tell if this article looks reactionary and premature, but to give more context on the potential outgoing, only one manager in Aberdeen’s history has a worse win percentage than the current gaffer. That is Mark McGhee. We all know how that turned out.
Stephen Glass, Jim Goodwin and now Barry Robson, it is not a good look for Cormack.
What Has Gone Wrong for Robson?
The tactics, game management, the stubbornness not to change, and the lack of rotation after Europe. Four of the many reasons that Robson is too naive to be the manager of one of Scotland’s biggest football clubs.
As an example, PAOK Salonika. To give him some credit, the Aberdeen boss sometimes gets it spot on when it comes to setting up against better opposition. For the vast majority of that Europa Conference League fixture, the Dons looked comfortable and somewhat in control. They were tenacious, battling, forcing the Greeks into mistakes, and clinical on the counter. I can confidently say that was one of the best 70 minutes of my life. But then disaster struck – a triple substitution that instantly took the wind out the Dons’ sails meant PAOK smelled blood. Two quick-fire goals and a last minute penalty crushed the Granite City’s hopes of a first European win at Pittodrie in over 16 years, with many echoing on social media their main gripe with Robson – his decision making. His substitutions should have been spaced out, that way the momentum remains in Aberdeen’s favour. Such a radical change disrupted everything instantly as the new players could not acclimatise to the match.
Looking at Aberdeen’s league form, there have been too many matches this season where they have looked lethargic and leggy – despite having a big squad, the Dons seem hell-bent on not rotating. Or Dadia and Rhys Williams are still to make their competitive debuts. In addition, Pape Habib Gueye and Ester Sokler should be given more of a chance to prove themselves. Sokler especially looks like a bright player when given his moment. Robson’s other signings have looked like shrewd bargains, others have simply never been given a chance – some through no fault of their own, some through injury, and some through stubbornness in poor systems.
Aberdeen’s domestic tactics against similar/weaker opposition has been less-than-desired. A couple of years ago, Aberdeen released what they believed to be their footballing philosophy when Dave Cormack took over from former chairman Stuart Milne.
“The Club is aiming to inspire fans with an exciting brand of football that has its roots in homegrown talent. The philosophy sets out how the Club will strive to produce winning performances that get supporters up off their feet, with intensity and pace. Adopting many of the principles which have brought the Club successes over the years, the philosophy is about creating a recognisable style of play that is firmly centred around the development of homegrown talent.”
– Aberdeen Football Club’s Media Team
The only true part of that statement is that homegrown talent are breaking through into the first team. Jack Mackenzie, Connor Barron and Ryan Duncan are now all regulars in the squad. Barron and Mackenzie especially are having great seasons. The vast majority of the time, when playing a team of similar calibre, Aberdeen resort to ‘hoofing’ the ball up the park, which stifles any creativity and clearly is not a good fit for the squad. It feels like at times they decide, “Ah, Duk is up there, lets boot it to him”.
Instead of calmly using their time on the ball, they rush a pass that is easy to read and easily defended. Nothing on the pitch screams ‘recognisable’.
Since Robson was appointed, Aberdeen have won 21% of their Premiership matches. In games where they concede the first goal, the Dons lose 100% of the time. If that is not damning, I do not know what is.
Who could replace him?
Marti Cifuentes is bound to be linked to a high-profile Scottish job again. The Hammarby boss was incredibly close to becoming Heart of Midlothian’s new manager, but in some fans’ minds the board went for a safer, cheaper option in former interim boss Steven Naismith – very similar to the Dons. He was also softly linked to the Aberdeen job. His proven track record of improving teams, his defensive stability, and his attacking principles is what Aberdeen desire the most.
Nathan Jones is available but could be a risk after his torrid spell with Southampton. Despite his glowing over-performance with Luton Town in the past, Jones tends to be quite outlandish and downright bewildering in his press conferences, and at times he has an ego. His high-pressing and direct footballing ideas would not be too much of a transition for the squad and a big name could galvanise the support.
Stephen Robinson would be very unrealistic – why would he leave a St Mirren side in the form of their lives for an Aberdeen team who are clearly in a dire need of a rebuild (again)?
It did not stop Jim Goodwin, with the lure of a bigger budget and larger fan base proving too much for him. The Northern Irishman has in the past helped teams punch above their weight. When you think of Robinson, you think of his Motherwell side that made cup finals and secured scalps against the bigger teams in the division. He utilises wingers, likes to press, and favours more of a passing game – something that would really benefit a certain ex-Liverpool midfielder and his teammates around him.
Dave has to get it right. It’s ‘Dave’ ja vu for him and for me – I wrote something very similar last season!
The next man in charge needs to be experienced, cut throat, and know what he is doing. If Robson can get his head screwed on in the next few games, I am willing to give him my vote of confidence once more. Right now, however, the pessimist in me says that I do not think he can turn it around. I sincerely hope I am wrong.

.png)



Comments