CM Punk: Is Phil Brooks really what’s “best for business”?

Never has a wrestler divided an already temperamental sporting fan-base as much as Phil Jack Brooks. The forty four year old is now a free agent after his recent firing with cause by All Elite Wrestling CEO/General Manager Tony Khan. Wrestling journalism is hit and miss, most stories are based on rumour and conjecture. Their non-stories always get their fans’ hopes up, but ultimately lead to nothing.
The childlike wonder of twists and turns in wrestling has been dead for a very long time. CM Punk returning to the resurgent WWE would be an incredible story. The ever-so-vocal personality was famously fired by the worldwide phenomenon on his own wedding day. The end of his tenure was filled with tension, arguments, and falling outs with higher ups – making sure to burn every bridge possible before he exited the company for good. Or so we thought. It is heavily rumoured from the usual suspects at the Wrestling Observer that everybody’s favourite silver tongued Chicago native is seriously close to wrestling for the world’s number one sports entertainment brand once again.
He seems to have caught the wrestling bug again, which is surely good for “the business” right? An anonymous, yet now very vocal, internal WWE source (BWE) has backed up these claims. They have hinted numerous times on X (formally known as Twitter) that a deal was close between the two, but no agreement has been reached. Mr Punk is quite the charismatic figure who can hold the audience in the palm of his hand, a skill quite rare to possess. What he lacks in the ring in this day and age he can make up for with promo work. The addition of such a popular figure will have many positives.
The number of merchandise sales WWE could gain would be insurmountable – the opportunity to prise back the casual fan cannot be missed and the opportunity to steal AEW’s poster boy as of late could be exactly the petty but brilliant move that would assert WWE’s grip on the wrestling world. While there are clear benefits to this move, the obvious elephant in the room has to be addressed. His attitude in recent times has left a lot to be desired. The famous “Brawl Out” and Jack Perry incidents at his previous employer have reaffirmed some fears that he has not changed in the slightest. His gimmick is not really a gimmick at all, “shoot” and “kayfabe” Punk are one in the same in many ways. Both are not afraid to disrupt authority and proudly express their opinion.
The locker room may agree on this stance. WWE World Heavyweight Champion Seth Rollins has famously shared his opinion on the record numerous times.
“Philly Phil, stay away. Stay away, you cancer, get away from me forever. I don’t like Phil, he’s a jerk. Did we just figure that out? Everybody in the room is like, ‘did he say that?’ Yeah, he’s a jerk. Come on. We figured it out over there, we knew it over here. I don’t want him back. Go do something else. Bye bye. See you later,”
– WWE World Heavyweight Champion Seth Rollins
In addition, WWE’s Chief Content Officer Paul “Triple H” Levesque famously did not get on well with Punk, but now seems to be willing to work with him if there is a mutual benefit. It is quite the dilemma, sacrifice months and months of storytelling for a retro feel good baby face run? Or face the wrath of a man who clearly alienates his co workers. Personally, I say go for it. This is exactly the business decision that is a win-win for Triple H. Bring him in and you can make bank on a performer who can still perform at an extremely high level.
What if he gets up to his old tricks? You can feel vindicated that your previous distrust in someone has been proven right, showcasing to the world he is what you say he is. This could be the chance Phil is looking for if he wants to earn redemption, as his reputation in the wrestling world is incredibly mixed, motivation is a powerful drug, and he has that in spades. The chance for him to have feuds with Cody Rhodes, Seth Rollins, Shinsuke Nakamura, Sami Zayn and even the unconquerable Roman Reigns, could be very interesting, especially if a certain “American Nightmare” wants to finish his story at Wrestlemania.
I would say it is way too good of an opportunity to pass up, but would not be surprised that the constant clues and references to his career on WWE television as of late lead to nowhere, he is a ticking time bomb, but one that can be managed if given the right amount of caution. Risk it.

.png)



Comments