Parliament To Debate: What is the Right to Recovery Bill?
Former Scottish Conservative leader Douglas Ross has urged his fellow electorates to “put politics aside” as Holyrood is set to debate his proposed Right to Recovery committee Bill today at 2pm.
The proposal is at stage one of the legislation process. This means that it has undergone intense scrutiny by the Health, Social Care and Sport committee, who expressed concern about the focus of the bill, stating that it was too narrow minded and that the word choice of “addiction” should be changed, to reflect more modern terms.
“The aims of the Right to Addiction Recovery Bill are laudable, however, there is a risk that creating a legal right will distract from ongoing work to improve services for people with an alcohol problem.
But what exactly is the Right to Recovery Bill? And what are the roadblocks to the legislation getting passed into law by our elected representatives?
Despite recent statistics showing progress, Scotland remains the drug capital of Europe; an unwanted moniker for the country that has been established since 2018.

The bill proposes that individuals with a formally diagnosed addiction disorder should be treated by a relevant professional within a three week timeframe. Charities and even independent colleges have expressed concerns about what they believe to be oversights in Ross’ proposal. In comment to EN4News, a spokesman for the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh stated that they welcome the debate on the manner but expressed concern of the timeline specified by Mr Ross, stating that the independent body “remains unconvinced that it will in itself deliver the improvements desired”.

“We welcome the Health, Social Care & Sport Committee’s Stage one report on the Bill and consider it objective and thorough. We agree with the Committee members who have said that the Bill, if it proceeds to stage two, will require significant amendments to improve it”.
“The College is committed to working with the Scottish Government, MSPs and all other stakeholders to tackle Scotland’s drug and alcohol addiction and deaths crises and we would emphasise that the views of expert clinicians and addiction specialists must be at the centre of the ongoing debate.”
Dr Alastair MacGilchrist of the Scottish Health Action on Alcohol Problems (SHAAP) stated for this bill to work, local services need vital investment, echoing concerns from the Health Social Care and Sport committee. This news was released before the Scottish Government announced a fresh boost to this sector, professing that they will spend two million pounds for residential rehabilitation in Scotland.
“The aims of the Right to Addiction Recovery Bill are laudable, however, there is a risk that creating a legal right will distract from ongoing work to improve services for people with an alcohol problem.
“It is vital that we remove barriers to accessing treatment, yet the Bill requires a diagnosis of addiction which would mean that many people without a diagnosis would be excluded.
“We don’t actually know how many people require treatment for alcohol problems and there is significant unmet needs. We need a comprehensive needs assessment so that services are there for everyone who needs it, rather than a legal right to treatment for what is only a small proportion of people with alcohol problems.
“While we need to improve treatment, we also need to see action on prevention, including uprating of minimum unit pricing, alcohol marketing restrictions and an increase in duty. These will help to reduce alcohol harm at a population level.”
We will find out later on today on whether the legislation will move to Stage 2.

.png)



Comments